Vintage / Classic 80's G1 My Little Pony collectibles for sale in the Erie, PA area.

I'm parting with my collections, because I need the money, but mostly because I live in small apartments now and don't have space.

I will discount when you buy multiple items! ^_^ I don't want to be selling piece by piece, so individual prices are higher. ~ If interested: Take whole MLP collection for $750, and save a few hundred, or $700 without the 90s G2 lot.

I don't have a car, so you need to be able to meet in North East.
If buying over $100, I can use part to pay for a ride to meet in eastside Erie.
However, that's very limited and usually only on weekends.

All items are from a smoke-free home.

please contact me at

Also check out :
~ 90s MIP playsets & ponies ~ Collector Ponies ~ TAF Baby Ponies set ~ Customized Dream Castle & rare Sparkle Ponies ~
~ Sticker Books ~ Fan Club & Collectibles in Binder ~ Story Cards in Binder ~

Also parting with book collections with collectible accessories to their series :
~ Anne McCaffrey - Dragonriders ~ Mercedes Lackey - Velgarth/Valdemar ~ book misc. ~
~ and Sailormoon collectibles ~ other vintage items (Care Bear, Gummi Bear, SheRa, Fantasy Filly) ~

On this page are some MIP MOC MIB, and below those are Rare & Unique Ponies.

My Little Pony Merry-Go-Round Game MIB $40

This vintage 80s MLP game is ultra RARE and FACTORY SEALED mint in box and comes with rare original 80s advertisement for it.

European Sunshine Pony Main Sail MOC $100

Vintage mint in package / mint on card and from overseas, her package is in excellent condition. I believe the languages on it are Dutch and French. She's not only a rare mint in package My Little Pony Sunshine Pony, but she's also one of the very collectible foreign versions. These often go for 3-400 in auctions, but I don't have online accounts and don't ship. So, you get a deal. ^_~

Ultra Rare MIP/MOC Firefly's Adventure vhs set $250

The vintage 80s original MLP movie came in a collectible set with pink vhs tape and a new version of Firefly with dark blue hair and a new pose. The package is in excellent condition. The last one I saw mint in package sold for over $400. I've only seen two mint in package for sale in probably twenty years.

Can include the original Firefly and her baby with purchase of the vhs set: The original Firefly has lighter blue hair and a glittery symbol. She and her symbol are in excellent condition, and she has her original ribbon and her story card. ~ Original Baby Firefly still has most of her original curl, her original ribbon, rattle and bear brush and her story card. She's also in excellent condition.

Great for collectors to have the MIP movie set along with the original version of Firefly and her baby, along with their character stories. So, I'll only sell the original Firefly and Baby Firefly separately after MOC movie set sells, if purchaser of movie doesn't also want the loose ponies.

10th Anniversary Birthday Pony set $25

These are two versions of the 10th Anniversary MLP Birthday Pony along with an original ad that includes her. Though advertised with yellow, she was never released with yellow on her, and she was released with differing colors of tinsel. Both are still a nice clean white.

The original release (above) has magenta and dark blue tinsel in her hair. $15 by herself, or $20 for her with the ad. (ad by itself $5)

The later version (below) has just medium blue tinsel in her hair. $10 by herself.

According to, the prototypes of this Pony had magenta and blue tinsel (actual prototypes also had yellow in the symbols), so I believe the version I have with magenta and dark blue tinsel was the first run/release and later changed to plain medium-blue, the other one I have. [Of course, someone changed the information since the last time I was there. 9_9 Now, it's almost somewhat random and not as detailed in the description, and I remember better photos.]

Chuck E. Cheese Pony $25

Many fans call her "Charlie". She was exclusive to Chuck E. Cheese restaurant customers. This one is in excellent to like new condition with beautiful hair.

Baby Christmas Pony / "Baby Stockings" $10

Baby Christmas Pony was only available through mailorder from Rice Krispies cereal and is one of only three Christmas Ponies ever made in the original 80s G1 MLP line, as well as the only baby Christmas pony. This one has beautiful hair and is still nicely white. The red bow on her tail is a Christmas decoration - she didn't come with it. She has the same symbol as the 3rd Christmas Pony called Stockings (extremely hard to find), so most fans call her Baby Stockings. ~ I have a one-owner, only watched a few times, fun movie vhs "A Very Minty Christmas", which you can have with her for no additional cost.

I also have a stray Flutter Pony wing. Free with purchase of other items, or $5 by itself.

back to top